9 Books Like The Midnight Library

Hand-picked recommendations for readers who loved The Midnight Library by Matt Haig.

Staff Pick
The Midnight Library

If you loved...

The Midnight Library

by Matt Haig

We found 9 books with similar themes, writing style, and atmosphere. Each one hand-picked for readers who couldn't put down The Midnight Library.

Similar Reads
Life After Life
View Details

Life After Life

Kate Atkinson

2013
18 editions

This novel explores the concept of alternate lives and second chances through a woman who repeatedly dies and relives different versions of her life.

Recursion
View Details

Recursion

Blake Crouch

2019
9 editions

A mind-bending thriller that delves into the nature of memory and reality, similar to 'The Midnight Library's' exploration of what-ifs.

The First Fifteen Lives of Harry August
View Details

The First Fifteen Lives of Harry August

Claire North

2014
6 editions

Follows a man who lives his life over and over, retaining memories of his past lives, echoing the theme of exploring different life paths.

This is how it always is
View Details

This is how it always is

Laurie Frankel

2017
10 editions

While focusing on family and identity, it touches on themes of acceptance and living authentically, resonating with the self-discovery aspect of 'The Midnight Library'.

The Invisible Life of Addie LaRue
View Details

The Invisible Life of Addie LaRue

V. E. Schwab

2015
32 editions

A woman makes a Faustian bargain for immortality and lives through centuries, exploring themes of regret, connection, and the meaning of a life lived.

Cloud Cuckoo Land
View Details

Cloud Cuckoo Land

Anthony Doerr

2021
20 editions

This novel weaves together multiple storylines across time, exploring the enduring power of stories and human connection, much like the interconnected lives in 'The Midnight Library'.

The Time Traveler's Wife
View Details

The Time Traveler's Wife

Audrey Niffenegger

2006
1 edition

A unique love story complicated by involuntary time travel, exploring the impact of choices and the nature of fate across different timelines.

The Ten Thousand Doors of January
View Details

The Ten Thousand Doors of January

Alix E. Harrow

2019
12 editions

A young woman discovers doors to other worlds, exploring themes of storytelling, destiny, and the power of choice in shaping one's reality.

Klara and the Sun
View Details

Klara and the Sun

Kazuo Ishiguro

2019
27 editions

An artificial friend observes human behavior and contemplates love and existence, offering a unique perspective on life and connection, similar to Nora's introspective journey.

End of recommendations

Frequently Asked Questions

Quick answers about books like The Midnight Library

What should I read after The Midnight Library? +

If you enjoyed The Midnight Library by Matt Haig, try Life After Life, Recursion, The First Fifteen Lives of Harry August, This is how it always is, and The Invisible Life of Addie LaRue. Each one was hand-picked for similar themes, writing style, and atmosphere.

How many books are similar to The Midnight Library? +

We've curated 9 books with a similar feel to The Midnight Library. Explore books like The Midnight Library! Dive into thought-provoking fiction about alternate realities, second chances, and the meaning of life.

Are there books like The Midnight Library by Matt Haig? +

Yes — readers who loved The Midnight Library often pick up Life After Life, Recursion, and The First Fifteen Lives of Harry August. They share the qualities that made Matt Haig's book hard to put down.

What makes a book similar to The Midnight Library? +

This novel explores the concept of alternate lives and second chances through a woman who repeatedly dies and relives different versions of her life. A mind-bending thriller that delves into the nature of memory and reality, similar to 'The Midnight Library's' exploration of what-ifs.

Further Reading

Guides on tracking down the books you've half-forgotten

Only have a vibe? identify the genre first. Or describe the plot if you remember a scene.

Looking for a specific book you can't remember?

Describe it & we'll find it

Choose Your Shelf

Every reader is welcome. Pick the experience that fits your journey.

Browsing · Free

Browsing

For the casual book lover

Free

No account needed

  • Find books by plot description
  • AI-powered matching
  • Daily plot and cover puzzles
  • Last 7 days of the puzzle archive
  • Book details and purchase links
Start finding books
Membership · $5

Membership

For the devoted reader

$5 /month

Your personal book companion

  • Everything in the free plan
  • Full puzzle archive — every day, all the way back
  • Saturday themed mega-quiz, in your inbox
  • Deeper AI search across the catalog
  • Ad-free reading

The free plan is here to stay. We'll always help you find your forgotten books at no cost.

Ex Libris

What Membership gets you

The archive

The whole shelf, not just this week

Free readers get the last 7 days. Members get every plot and cover puzzle we've ever published. Browse back, pick a date, finish the ones you missed.

The weekend

A themed quiz, by post

Each weekend we send Members a themed quiz, built from books in your reading orbit. One author, one decade, one genre. In your inbox by Saturday morning.

The search

A slower, deeper way to find a book

Members get our web-grounded lane. It looks beyond the catalog and finds books from the foggy half-memories the fast lane gives up on.

The quiet

No ads, anywhere

The site stays quiet. No display ads on result pages, on the archive, or anywhere else you read.

Ask the librarian

Questions, answered

Can I cancel anytime?

Yes. From your Account page, two clicks opens the Stripe billing portal and you can stop renewal right there. You'll keep Member access until the end of the period you've already paid for.

What's it cost, exactly?

$5 USD per month, or $50 USD per year (that's two months free). Both options run through Stripe. Switch between them anytime from the billing portal.

Do I need a Member account to play the daily puzzle?

No. The daily plot and cover puzzles are free for everyone, and so is the last 7 days of the archive. Membership opens up everything older than that, plus the Saturday mega-quiz and the rest of what's listed above.

What happens to my streak if I cancel?

Your streak history stays. You can keep playing the daily puzzles for free after cancelling. You lose access to the full archive, the Saturday mega-quiz, and deeper AI search, and you'll see ads again.

Will more features be added?

Yes. We're working on saved reading lists, personalized recommendations, and a reading-history export. Members get all of these automatically as they ship, at the same price. No upgrade or new tier.

How do you handle payment info?

Stripe handles all of it. Your card never touches our servers. To update your card or download invoices, use the billing portal from your Account page.

Can I get a refund?

Yes. Email justin@whatisthatbook.com within 14 days of your first charge, monthly or annual, and we'll refund you in full. No questions asked. Full details on the refund policy page.