6 Books Found

Based on your description:

"The book goes between two POVs. One of them is in the past and is a girl in high school who pursues her teacher who leads the school play. The other POV is a boy, who accidentally hits a girl wth his car but she's okay. This girl turns out to be a new student at his high school, very quiet and reserved. We find out that this girl is actually the girl who pursued her teacher. The teacher and her ran away from their town and moved, and he is now pretending to be her dad in his new town to avoid suspicion. The boy catches on and saves her."